As you can see they are quite similar. I find SauceBox's Jungle green to
be more yellow and a lighter shade of green than Sugarpill's Midori.
Now, Oh La La was brighter and a smidge lighter than Dollipop.
I found the blues to be apples and oranges.
I don't think any are substitutes for another.
But all of the colors are lovely.
Now, the oranges. I think SauceBox's Wildflower
is less pink/red than Sugarpill's Flamepoint. It also
has a less chalky appearance on the skin.
Her are two that are altogether different from Sugarpill.
Spy is a lovely, shimmery vanilla shade, great for
highlighting the browbone and cheekbones.
Killer is a mid-tone, warm gray and I love it.
It's not blue-based and its very easy to use for
a smoky eye and NOT overdo it.
Now here's the price breakdown of each. Sugarpill's single shadows are $12 each. SauceBox Cosmetics' single shadows are $8 each. A quad palette from Sugarpill is $34. A quad palette from SauceBox is $26. And a 6-pan palette from SauceBox is $35-$38. While some things are not similar, other things are. And you know me, I am always looking for the best deal around. I am quite happy with all of my shadows.